
Is This the Greatest Invention Ever?
The surprising history of toilet paper
Learning Objective: to read a short informational text, then craft a constructed response that includes a claim, text evidence, and commentary
A Major Obstacle
Shutterstock.com
Ancient Greeks wiped with clay and stones. Ancient Romans used sponges and salt water or vinegar.
Toilet paper as we know it today is a relatively recent invention. But the first paper made for wiping was created in China about 700 years ago. It wasn’t until the 1850s that the idea spread beyond China. That’s when an American named Joseph Gayetty began selling sheets made from plant fiber that he called “medicated paper.” He encouraged people to use the sheets after using the bathroom.
Gayetty’s wipes weren’t popular though, and the next big step forward in TP technology didn’t happen until 1890. It was then that brothers Clarence and E. Irvin Scott came up with the idea of having one long sheet of paper wound around a roll. But the brothers faced a major obstacle in marketing their product: Nobody wanted to talk about it.
Today the brothers’ brand, Scott, proudly proclaims that its TP “gets the job done.” In the late 1800s, however, people were generally uncomfortable talking about what happened in the bathroom. In fact, the Scott brothers were so embarrassed by their own product that they didn’t take credit for it for about a decade.
What’s more, purchasing paper just for bathroom use would have seemed unusual and extravagant at the time the Scotts debuted their product. Americans typically used corncobs, moss, leaves, pages torn from catalogs and books, or other readily available items to clean themselves. But all that changed in the 1900s, when flush toilets and indoor plumbing became commonplace in American homes. Suddenly, people needed a product that wouldn’t clog or destroy plumbing systems. Yet talking about bathroom business remained taboo.
Enter a new era: Charmin.
Becoming Essential
Shutterstock.com
Americans, on average, each use a whopping 140 rolls or toilet paper a year!
In 1928, the Hoberg Paper Company realized it had to get creative if it wanted people to buy its toilet paper. The company came up with Charmin, a brand represented by an elegant woman. No mention of the product’s actual purpose appeared on the packaging. Charmin’s TP was a hit. (To this day, the brand still exists—now represented by a cuddly bear.)
As time went on, toilet paper became more and more popular. By the 1970s, TP had become indispensable. In fact, the product was considered so essential that people panicked when faced with the idea of running out of it. In 1973, a television host made a joke about a toilet paper shortage, and millions of people took him seriously. They rushed to the store to stock up—leading to an actual toilet paper shortage that lasted a month!
Time for Change?
The Granger Collection
In the 1800s, Americans read The Old Farmer’s Almanac to learn about gardening and the weather. Then they used the book’s pages to wipe!
In 2020, during the Covid-19 pandemic, there was another TP shortage, proving Americans still cannot fathom living without it. And indeed, toilet paper remains a big business. In a typical year, Americans spend about $9 billion on toilet paper, going through about 140 rolls of it per person.
Unfortunately, all that TP is wreaking havoc on our planet. According to Edge, a company that specializes in sustainability, 1 million trees are cut down annually to make the plush stuff we are used to. Is it time for a change?
There are other options that would be better for the environment. In Japan, high-tech toilet seats that combine a mini-shower and blow-dryer for the rear are popular. In many parts of the world, bidets—basins with faucets for bottom washing—are common. Both options eliminate the need for TP and are less damaging to the environment, but neither has really caught on in the U.S.
So for now, think twice about how many squares you use. Or look for TP made from recycled paper. It may be a tad rougher on your bottom, but it’s a lot softer on the planet.
Short Write: What are the pros and cons of toilet paper?
Answer this question in a well-organized paragraph. Use text evidence.
This article was originally published in the April 2025 issue.
Close Reading, Critical Thinking, Skill Building
1. Prepare to Read
(5 minutes)
Preview Vocabulary (5 minutes)
Project the Google Slides version of Vocabulary: Definitions and Practice on your whiteboard. Review the definitions and complete the activity as a class. Highlighted words: indispensable, sustainability, taboo. Audio pronunciations of the words and a read-aloud of the definitions are embedded on the slides. Optionally, print the PDF version or share the slideshow link directly to your LMS and have students preview the words and complete the activity independently before class.
2. Read and Discuss
(20 minutes)
For students’ first read, have them follow along as they listen to the audio read-aloud, located in the Resources tab in Teacher View and at the top of the story page in Student View.
Have students read the story again.
Optionally, divide students into groups to complete the Core Skills Workout: Central Ideas and Details activity. This graphic organizer asks students to identify the central idea and supporting details of each section of the article and the central idea of the article as a whole.
3. Write About It
(20 minutes)
Have students complete the Short Write Kit. This activity can be used to guide students as they write a claim, support it with text evidence, and provide commentary in response to the prompt on page 11 in the printed magazine and at the bottom of the digital story page:
What are the pros and cons of toilet paper? Use text evidence to support your ideas. Answer this question in a well-organized paragraph. Use text evidence.