A fountain drink and a tipped bucket spill popcorn in front of movie theater seats
Shutterstock.com

Do We Still Need Movie Theaters?

The Grand Cinema in Maplewood is on the verge of closing its doors. Willow says this theater is worth saving; Cameron thinks otherwise. Who makes the stronger argument?

By Natalie Hughes
From the September 2026 Issue

Learning Objective: Students will trace and evaluate two opposing arguments.

Lexile: 1030L

Standards

The Situation

The Grand Cinema in Maplewood is on the verge of closing its doors after 35 years, and town leaders want to know how the public feels. Do movie theaters matter anymore? Or are they relics of the past? Two teens weigh in.

YES

Movie theaters are worth saving.

By Willow Parker

These days, you can watch almost any movie without leaving the comfort of your couch. But if movie theaters closed, you would lose something you simply can’t re-create at home. For one thing, theaters offer a more immersive experience, with giant screens, booming sound systems, and technologies like IMAX and 4DX that pull you into the story. Sure, home technology is catching up, but even the best home theater setup can’t match the electric atmosphere that is created at the movies. Nothing can compare to sitting in a pitch-black room with few distractions, the sound rumbling through your seat and the screen towering in front of you.

Movie theaters also bring people together. When you’re in a theater, you’re experiencing a movie alongside everyone around you—laughing, gasping, cheering, and even crying together. In fact, some psychologists say that watching a movie together causes people to pick up on each other’s reactions—it’s a phenomenon called “emotional contagion,” in which feelings spread from person to person. This can make funny moments funnier, scary scenes scarier, and emotional moments more powerful. 

It’s no surprise, then, that 59 percent of Gen Alpha respondents say they prefer watching movies in theaters, according to a 2025 National Research Group study. That tracks: For me and my friends, hitting the Grand Cinema on a Friday night is one of our favorite things to do. It’s true that going to the movies can get expensive. But for many moviegoers, the higher-quality experience is worth the cost. 

So instead of closing, maybe the Grand Cinema should try something new to boost business. Many theaters are becoming dynamic entertainment centers that host community events, trivia nights, sing-alongs, special screenings, and opening night celebrations for big movie releases. I think the Grand should try it. That way, the beloved tradition of going to the movies doesn’t have to disappear in our town; it could just evolve into something even more special and enticing

NO

Movie theaters don’t matter anymore.

By Cameron Watts

For a long time, going to the movies was one of the most popular ways to spend a Friday night. Now, even with upgrades like luxury seating and special screenings, theaters are struggling to bring people in. Before the Covid-19 pandemic, ticket sales in the U.S. and Canada were $10 billion to $11 billion a year. In 2025, that number was about $8.7 billion. 

The truth is, streaming services have taken over, and it’s easy to see why. Yes, theaters offer a powerful, immersive experience. But for many viewers, convenience and comfort matter more. At home, you can watch whatever you want, wherever you want—your couch, your bed, your bathtub—without worrying about showtimes or crowds, or strangers kicking your seat. That’s hard to compete with.

Another big reason people are skipping theaters is the price. Today the average movie ticket in the U.S. costs around $16, with tickets for IMAX, 3D, and 4DX increasing the standard price. Add in snacks—popcorn and a drink can set you back $15 or more—and a night at the movies can quickly add up to $50 or more for just two people. Many of us feel it’s just not worth the investment.

Sure, seeing a movie in the theater can feel like an exciting way to come together as a community. But movie theaters are no longer the only places where we can gather to create those kinds of shared moments. Younger audiences are turning to other spaces—like social media, gaming, and streaming watch parties—to connect. For example, my friends and I host Minecraft game nights where we all play on the same server and chat the whole time. 

Movie theaters have a long history of entertaining Americans, but for many people, they’re no longer worth the time, cost, or effort. That’s why more viewers are choosing easier, cheaper, and more flexible ways to watch and connect. Instead of trying to hold on to movie theaters, maybe it’s time to embrace where entertainment is already heading: toward streaming services and online communities.

What does your class think?

Do We Still Need Movie Theaters?

Please enter a valid number of votes for one class to proceed.

Do We Still Need Movie Theaters?

Please select an answer to vote.

Do We Still Need Movie Theaters?

0%
0votes
{{result.answer}}
Total Votes: 0
Thank you for voting!
Sorry, an error occurred and your vote could not be processed. Please try again later.

Scavenger Hunt

Directions:

For each essay, complete the following steps on your own document:

1. Identify the central claim.

2. Identify the reasons.

3. Identify two pieces of supporting evidence.

4. Identify the counterclaim.

5. Identify the rebuttal

Now decide: Who makes the stronger argument?

This article was originally published in the September 2026 issue.

video (1)
Slideshows (1)
Audio ()
Activities (4)
Answer Key (1)
video (1)
Slideshows (1)
Audio ()
Activities (4)
Answer Key (1)
Text-to-Speech