Image of a lost dog in a forest
Illustrations by Gumiho

Facing Forever

A strange place. A lost dog. And a shocking discovery that will change everything.

By Bobbie Pyron
From the April 2023 Issue

Learning Objective: to analyze how and why a character changes over the course of a story

Lexile: 750L
Other Key Skills: allusion, inference, mood, figurative language
AS YOU READ

Think about how meeting Boo changes Nathan.

The first time we saw him, my little sister thought he was a ghost. In some ways she was right, though there’s not really a word for what he was.

We’d parked in the Ponce de León Travel Park outside St. Augustine, Florida—stop five in the longest family vacation in the history of family vacations.  My family is OK, but after two weeks crammed into a rented RV with my parents and sister, I was losing my mind. 

Dad said we needed this vacation, especially Mom, after everything that had happened. Maybe so, but I didn’t see how driving from Maryland to Florida would make things right. I didn’t see how it would make things the way they used to be.

Shutterstock.com

The expression “Heinz 57” comes from an 1890s advertising slogan telling consumers about Heinz’s wide variety of products.

As I sat on the picnic table watching what Dad called “swamp fog” creep toward us from the forest on the other side of the park, I wondered what my friends were doing back home. Then thinking about home made me think about who wasn’t there anymore, and my throat tightened.

“Nathan, look!” Maggie said, jolting me out of my thoughts. On the other side of the park, something had emerged from the misty shadows of the forest. 

Maggie grabbed my hand. “It’s a ghost!” 

I pulled Maggie a bit closer and squinted into the fog. Then I said, “It’s just a dog.”

The dog stopped about 15 feet from us and wagged his tail eagerly. He was large and mostly black, with splashes of white on his chest and the tops of his paws. He seemed to me a mix of everything—a real Heinz 57, as Grandpa would have said. 

The dog trotted over and looked up at us with smiling eyes. 

“Who do we have here?” Dad asked as he brought out plates of burgers and chips. 

“I don’t know,” I shrugged, scratching the small white star on the dog’s chest. “He just strolled up.” 

“Must belong to another camper,” Mom said definitively. She stood beside me and squeezed my shoulder. 

Maybe, but there were no other campers, at least none in sight. We’d stumbled across this place when Dad had taken yet another wrong turn. It wasn’t even on our RV camp map.

Maggie wrapped her arms around the dog’s neck. “He’s mine,” she said. “I’m naming him Boo.” 

Boo was Maggie’s nickname for Grandpa Lou. Suddenly, I felt a thunderstorm brewing in my stomach.  

I got up and ran into the RV.

“Sorry!” Maggie called out.

“It’s OK,” I heard Dad say as I slammed the door. “He just needs some time alone.”

When I came back outside that evening, Boo was still there. He followed close as we explored the campground. It was strangely desolate. A gust of wind blew the rusty playground swings back and forth, making a creaking sound. 

“It’s creepy here,” I said to Dad.

“Must be the off-season,” he shrugged. “Besides,” he added, grinning, “isn’t it nice having the place to ourselves?” 

When it was time for bed, Maggie insisted Boo stay, but Dad said we had to let him go because he belonged to someone else. I opened the RV door to let Boo out, but he just stared up at me and whined. 

“Go on,” I said softly. Finally, he hopped out reluctantly, and I watched him slowly walk across the park and disappear into the trees. 

The next morning, Dad and Maggie packed up for a day at the amusement park. 

“Nate, you coming?” Dad asked.

“I’ll pass,” I said. Going to an amusement park seemed like the wrong thing to do somehow.

Mom smiled. “I’ll pass too. I want to go through our vacation photos and hang out with Nate.”

After they left, Mom perched next to me on the picnic table. “Want to go for a walk, maybe talk a bit?”

I hopped off the table and jammed my hands into my pockets. “Maybe later,” I said, not meeting her eyes. “I’m going to check out the forest, see if I can find where Boo lives.”

Mom sighed. I knew what she wanted to say: Being mad at the world won’t bring him back. You have to talk about it sometime. Things she’d already said.

Instead she called out, “Be careful. There’s no telling what’s out there!”

I made my way across the park to the edge of the woods. The vines were so dense I couldn’t see more than a few feet in front of me. Spanish moss hung in long silver tendrils from the trees. I glanced back at our RV. Maybe this wasn’t such a good idea.

Just then, something rustled in the leaves. Boo pushed through a thick bunch of palmettos and wagged his tail. 

“Hey, you,” I said, patting his head. “Are you going to show me where you live?”

Boo let out a small bark, turned, and disappeared through the wall of vegetation. 

I plunged in after him, stumbling over twisting tree roots protruding from the ground. Vines clawed at my shirt and tore at my legs and feet, scratching my skin, but I kept going. I dropped to my hands and knees, crawling under a branch, and my foot struck something sharp. The ground was wet. Swamp water seeped between my fingers. 

Standing up, I scraped a sticky spider web off my face and peered into the woods for Boo. There was no way I wanted to get lost in this jungle.

I heard his whisper-bark and spied him standing in a small patch of sunlight on a barely discernible trail. 

And then he was gone again. 

I looked down. Blood soaked my flip-flops. Scrapes and cuts laced my feet. A deep gash on my heel throbbed. 

Behind me, I couldn’t see anything but foliage. It was as if nothing else had ever existed. 

There was no turning back now. I took a deep breath and forged ahead. 

Boo was standing in a clearing when I finally caught up to him. Beyond him, in the shadows, sat a dilapidated building surrounded by a weedy parking lot. The windows and doors were all boarded up. A crumbling fountain sat in front. I could tell it had been beautiful once, with intricate curls etched into the stone. Now it brimmed with stagnant water and bugs. 

A large, faded sign on top of the building declared, “Eternal Springs Resort.” 

Boo leaned against me. One of his hind legs trembled.

“You OK?” I asked. In reply, he limped behind the building along an overgrown path. 

“Not another bushwhack in the swamp,” I groaned.

I found Boo in a sunlit patch on the bank of a stream, drinking. Gingerly, he eased himself into the water. 

“Great idea,” I said, kicking off my flip-flops. I put my feet in the cold water, watching the blood wash away. 

Closing my eyes, I listened. Leaves rustling. Birds chirping. Stream gurgling. A magical oasis in the swamp. 

“Grandpa would have loved this,” I whispered. 

Grandpa, so full of life, so . . .

Woof! 

I looked up and saw Boo prancing toward me with a stick in his mouth, like a puppy. Whatever had been wrong with his back leg seemed fine now. His limp was completely gone. 

I chased him along the stream for a while, wrestling the stick from him and playing fetch. Finally, I flopped on the ground and Boo curled up beside me, panting. I buried my face in wet dog fur and felt the tight knot that had been twisted up inside me for weeks start to loosen. 

“Let’s go,” I finally told Boo. 

And that’s when I noticed it: The skin on my feet was completely healed—new as a baby’s.

Illustration by Gumiho

What is the Fountain of Youth?

According to legend, the Fountain of Youth is a natural spring with magical waters that reverse aging and basically make you immortal. Back in the early 1500s, a conquistador named Juan Ponce de León supposedly embarked on a quest to find it. One of several alleged sites of this fountain is in St. Augustine, Florida.

Since there was no sign of Boo’s family, Mom and Dad said we could adopt him. But before we took him home with us to Maryland, Mom wanted to have him checked out. 

We found a vet just down the road from our campground. Dr. Brewster wasn’t much taller than I was, but she looked like she could wrestle an alligator.  

“Seems healthy,” she concluded after checking Boo’s eyes and ears.

“How old do you think he is?” I asked. 

“Could be 5 or 6.” She took off Boo’s collar. “Hmmm. These tags look old. Ancient, really. I’ll run a check on the number.” 

Dr. Brewster left the exam room. When she returned a few moments later, she was shaking her head. 

“According to these tags, this dog is 75 years old. The tags were registered to a dog named Roscoe in 1947.”

Dad frowned. “Well, the records must be wrong.”

“My granddaddy was the vet then. He kept impeccable records,” Dr. Brewster said. “It’s more likely that Roscoe’s tags ended up on Boo somehow.”

“Or he found the Fountain of Youth,” Mom said with a chuckle.

Everyone laughed—except me. A strange feeling was washing over me . . .

When we got back to the campground, I told Dad that we couldn’t keep Boo.

“I’m pretty sure I know where his family is,” I lied. “It would be wrong to take him.”

“Are you sure?” Dad seemed surprised.

I was. Somehow that stream was keeping Boo alive. Bringing him home with us meant he would die one day. 

“We have to leave him here,” I said firmly.

“But you said . . .” Maggie sobbed. 

“Get out of here!” I yelled at Boo. 

Boo looked at me, confused. 

“Go home!” I shouted, shooing him away. 

Boo slunk into the woods, head low, tail down, whimpering.

Mom touched my arm. “Nate . . .”

I jerked away and ran into the RV, feeling horrible and nauseous and hating this vacation more than anything.

I couldn’t sleep that night. Maggie had cried and cried and cried. “You said Boo was ours,” she’d wailed over and over.

“Nathan’s right, honey,” Mom had said. “Boo belongs here. With his family.”

We’re his family,” Maggie had whined. “We love him.”

Suddenly, I remembered my last day with Grandpa. I’d been sitting next to him in the hospital room when he’d opened his eyes and taken my hand. 

“Don’t look so sad, Nate,” he had said. “It’s my time. I’m ready.”

I wanted to shout at him, “No! You can’t leave me!” 

But I hadn’t said anything. 

“I’ve had a long life,” Grandpa had whispered, gripping my hand harder. “A life filled with love and family. What more could I ask for?”

I sat up in bed. 

I knew exactly what I had to do.

I slipped out of bed, tiptoed to the door, and stepped outside. 

A wall of swamp fog had crept in from the forest, enveloping the parking lot entirely. I couldn’t even see the playground. 

The thought of looking for Boo at night filled me with dread, but before I had taken a single step, I heard a familiar sound.

Woof! 

Boo emerged from the fog, eyes shining, tail wagging. I knelt beside him and buried my face in his damp fur. 

“Come on,” I whispered. “Let’s go home.”

Writing Prompt

Why does Nathan struggle to make the decision he makes at the end of the story? Why does he make the choice he did? Answer both questions in a well-organized essay. 

This story was originally published in the April 2023 issue.

Slideshows (1)
Audio ()
Activities (12)
Quizzes (1)
Answer Key (1)
Slideshows (1)
Audio ()
Activities (12)
Quizzes (1)
Answer Key (1)
Step-by-Step Lesson Plan

Close Reading, Critical Thinking, Skill Building

Essential Questions: Would immortality be a blessing or a curse? How can we cope with loss? What gives life meaning?

1. PREPARING TO READ (20 MINUTES)

Do-Now: Journal and Discuss (10 minutes)

  • Project the following journal prompt on your whiteboard: Make a pro/con list for immortality (the ability to live forever). Then respond to the following question: Would immortality be a blessing or a curse? 
  • Invite students to share their responses. 

Preview Vocabulary (10 minutes)

  • Project the Vocabulary Slideshow on your whiteboard. Review the definitions and complete the activity as a class. The audio pronunciations of the words and a read-aloud of the definitions are embedded on the slides. Highlighted words: bushwhack, definitively, dilapidated, discernible, impeccable, oasis.

2. READING AND DISCUSSING (45 MINUTES)

  • Read the As You Read box on page 28 or at the top of the digital story page.
  • Point out the directions at the top of the column on the far-right side of page 29 and read them aloud to your students.
  • Optionally, for students’ first read, have them follow along as they listen to the audio read-aloud, located in the Resources tab in Teacher View and at the top of the story page in Student View.
  • Divide students into groups to read the story again, pausing to discuss the close-reading questions that appear in the margins of the print magazine or by clicking on the bolded words on the digital story page. Have students record their answers in their own document or on the Close Reading and Critical Thinking activity.

Close-Reading Questions (30 minutes)

  • What does the name of the travel park refer to? (allusion) Juan Ponce de León is the name of the conquistador who is said to have embarked on a quest to find the legendary Fountain of Youth. The author names the travel park after him to bring to readers’ minds the idea of the legendary spring that reverses aging and makes people immortal. [Allusion is a literary device: an implied or indirect reference to a person, place, thing, or another work of literature. Allusions are based on the assumption that there is a body of knowledge shared by the author and the reader and that the reader will understand the author’s reference.]
  • What can you infer from Nathan’s reaction to the name Maggie chooses? (inference) Based on details Nathan reveals in the story’s opening, readers can infer that Nathan’s family has suffered some sort of loss, perhaps the death of a loved one. Nathan says, “Dad said we needed this vacation, especially Mom, after everything that had happened” and “thinking about home made me think about who wasn’t there anymore.” When Nathan becomes physically ill and runs away after Maggie calls the dog “Boo,” her nickname for their Grandpa Lou, readers can infer that it was Grandpa Lou who recently died—and that Nathan is really struggling with the loss.
  • What mood is the author creating in this paragraph? (mood) The author is creating an eerie mood in this paragraph. The campground’s emptiness, the gusty wind, and the creaky noises create a feeling of uneasiness that’s almost frightening.
  • Why is this an important moment for Nathan? What knot is starting to loosen? (character) Up to this point, Nathan has not been enjoying the family vacation. He’s mad at the world about his grandpa’s death, but he’s not talking to anyone about it, and he’s not allowing himself to live in the moment or find moments of joy. For example, when Nathan’s family goes to the amusement park, he doesn’t go because it “seemed like the wrong thing to do somehow.” But in this moment at the stream with Boo, Nathan finds a feeling of peace, even joy. He listens to the leaves rustling, the birds chirping, and the stream gurgling; he appreciates the beauty of what he calls a “magical oasis in the swamp”; he thinks about how much Grandpa would have loved it. Having positive thoughts of Grandpa and finding joy in playing with Boo loosens the knot of grief that Nathan has been dealing with since Grandpa’s death. 
  • What does this detail tell you about Dr. Brewster? (figurative language) This detail tells you that Dr. Brewster looks strong and/or tough. 
  • What is Nathan realizing? (inference) Nathan is realizing that Boo really is 75 years old because Boo has been swimming in and drinking from the Fountain of Youth. Nathan understands this from the fact that after he and Boo got in the stream in the swamp, Boo’s limp went away and he pranced around like a puppy, and the cuts on Nathan’s feet were healed.
  • What home is Nathan referring to? (inference) Nathan is referring to his family’s home in Maryland.
  • As a class, discuss the following questions.

Critical-Thinking Questions (5 minutes)

  • Why do you think Nathan decides to take Boo home at the end of the story? Do you think Nathan made the right choice? Why or why not? Nathan decides to bring Boo home to Maryland because he believes that having a life filled with love and family will be better for Boo than living forever on his own at the abandoned campground. You understand this because it is remembering what Nathan’s grandpa said just before he died—“I’ve had a long life. A life filled with love and family. What more could I ask for?”—that leads Nathan to his decision about Boo. Answers to the second question will vary. 
  • Would you bathe in the stream if given the chance? Answers will vary. 
  • Compare how Maggie and Nate react to the death of Grandpa Lou and to the idea of leaving Boo. What point might the author be making by presenting these contrasting characters? Answers will vary. Sample answer: Maggie and Nate react very differently to the death of Grandpa Lou and to the idea of leaving Boo. For example, Maggie names the dog they find after Grandpa Lou, while Nate runs off to be alone when he thinks of Grandpa Lou. Maggie is devastated at the thought of leaving Boo, while Nate—at first—would rather be without Boo than for Boo to die. The author is most likely trying to make the point that we all experience grief and other powerful emotions in our own unique ways.

3. SKILL BUILDING AND WRITING (30 MINUTES)

  • Have students complete the Writing Planner: Nathan’s Decision. This activity will help them organize their ideas in preparation for the writing prompt on page 31 in the printed magazine and at the bottom of the digital story page.
  • Alternatively, have students choose a culminating task from the Choice Board, a menu of differentiated activities.

4. CONNECTED READING

Text-to-Speech