Article
BACKGROUND ART: GARY HANNA

Killer Smog

In 1952, the deadliest environmental disaster in england’s history changed our ideas about the air we breathe

By Lauren Tarshis
From the Issue

Learning Objective: to synthesize information from two texts about air pollution

AS YOU READ

What causes air pollution?

Killer Smog

In 1952, the deadliest environmental disaster in England's history changed our ideas about the air we breathe

Like so many terrible things, the dark cloud seemed to appear out of nowhere. It swept over London, England—black and poisonous. It brought terror and sickness. It would kill 12,000 people. 

This was not a monster from a nightmare, an F5 tornado, or an alien spaceship. This terrifying killer was air—a massive cloud of toxic, polluted air. For five days, it blanketed London, causing fear, panic, and death. It became known as the Killer Smog of 1952, and it is one of the deadliest environmental disasters in history.

COURTESY OF BRIAN BONE

Brian Bone, about two years before the Killer Smog, with his German shepherd, Tarzan

Plunged Into Darkness

December 5, 1952, was a quiet day. Nine-year-old Brian Bone was at home with his parents and 15-year-old brother, Hugh. When Brian opened the back door to let out his dog, Tarzan, he noticed that the morning was damp and smoky. But that wasn’t unusual for London at that time of year. The German shepherd trotted into the fenced-in backyard, and Brian shut the door and went about his day.

It was only later, when Brian went to call the dog in, that he realized something was horribly wrong. The hazy morning had turned midnight black. The air had a sharp smell—a mixture of chemicals and rotten eggs. Brian and his parents called for Tarzan, but the dog had escaped through a hole in the fence. Normally, the shepherd would have been able to sniff his way home. But even a dog’s powerful sense of smell was no match for the smothering smog. For hours the family searched the neighborhood, braving the darkness as they called for Tarzan. The dog remained hopelessly lost.

Across London, millions of people had been plunged into darkness. Buses screeched to a halt. Trains stopped on their tracks. Cars crashed. People stumbled along the streets, unable to find their way home. A few got so lost they fell into the Thames River and drowned. Being indoors provided no escape. Black air crept under doors and through keyholes, filling up homes and offices and hospitals.

What was happening?

CENTRAL PRESS/HULTON ARCHIVE/GETTY IMAGES (LONDON)

WHEN DAY TURNED TO NIGHT

Londoners make their way through the darkened streets.

Pea-Soup Smog

THE FOG IN LITERATURE

In his 1853 novel Bleak House, Charles Dickens used the London fog as a symbol of society’s problems.

For centuries, London had been known for its fog, a swirling white mist that wrapped itself around the city on chilly days. The fog was as much a part of London as the Big Ben clock and Buckingham Palace. It appeared in countless paintings and inspired celebrated poems and haunting ghost stories.

True, it made London gloomy at times, but the fog was natural and harmless. Fog, after all, is simply microscopic drops of water trapped in the air.

By the 1800s, however, as the city grew more crowded and modern, it wasn’t only fog swirling around London. It was also pollution from factory smokestacks and millions of home chimneys. Much of this pollution came from burning coal, which produced an especially sooty and oily smoke. On foggy days, this smoke stuck to the drops of water in the air; imagine trillions of tiny water bubbles slathered with dirty oil, filling up every inch of open space.

In 1905, this dark and dirty fog got an official name: smog. By then, smog was already a problem in London. It was especially bad on cold winter days. When the temperature dropped, people burned more coal to keep warm.

Smoke belching out of 12 million home chimneys created hideously green “pea soup” smog.

A Fact of Life?

Air pollution wasn’t a problem only in London. The early 1900s were a time of growth for cities across Europe as well as the United States. Smog from factories and steel mills blanketed American cities like Pittsburgh and Cleveland. It turned cities ugly and smelled terrible. Kids playing outdoors would return home with blackened clothes, their lashes and brows coated with dark slime that could be removed only with strong detergent. Many people assumed that nothing could be done to make the air cleaner.

In London, coal was the cheapest way to heat a home, and most Londoners could not afford cleaner heating systems. The owners of factories and power plants insisted that reducing pollution would be too expensive. And what would happen if they had to close their factories? People would lose their jobs.

Smog, it seemed, was just a fact of modern urban life.

MONTY FRESCO/HULTON ARCHIVE/GETTY IMAGES

A policeman uses a torch to direct traffic through the smog.

A True Disaster

What few people understood was that smog wasn’t just dirty and smelly—it was also dangerous. It contained toxic chemicals and particulates—specks of unburned coal. As Brian and his family searched outside for Tarzan, their lungs were filling with this poison.

Even before scientists fully understood how smog damages the body, there were signs that it was harmful. On pea-soup smog days in London, schoolkids would be hunched over their desks, wheezing and hacking as they tried to do to their work. Elderly people would collapse in the streets. Emergency rooms routinely filled with patients showing signs of smog-related respiratory problems, such as asthma and pneumonia. Chemicals and particulates in smog can damage the lungs—permanently. Still, decades went by and government leaders took few steps to reduce air pollution.

But then came the smog of 1952.

This smog was different from others before it, more extreme and longer lasting. The unusually cold weather meant that people were burning more coal than usual to stay warm. There was no wind, nothing to clear away the smog.

So day after day, London remained dark. Schools stayed closed. Workers couldn’t get to their jobs. Even funerals were canceled; grieving relatives couldn’t see well enough to drive from churches to cemeteries to bury their loved ones.

By day three of the smog, there was some good news at the Bone house: Tarzan had somehow made his way home. But Brian couldn’t do much celebrating, because he was sick in bed with a burning, painful cough. He felt as though the smog itself was trapped inside his chest.

All around London, others were getting sick too—thousands and thousands of people. At first, most doctors believed that people were suffering from the flu or other typical winter illnesses. Even scientists did not immediately make a direct connection between the smog and the growing number of coughing, wheezing people staggering into hospitals.

Soon it became clear that London was in the grips of a true disaster. The smog wasn’t just making people sick.

It was killing them.

By the time the smog finally cleared on the fifth day, more than 4,000 people had died. In the coming months, roughly 8,000 more would die from illnesses related to the smog.

AMERICA’S TOXIC BREW

In 1948, the smog in Donora, Pennsylvania, turned lethal, sickening half the town and causing 20 deaths. The air was polluted by the city’s railroad yards and steel and zinc plants. The tragedy led to the Air Pollution Control Act of 1955—the first federal law aimed at reducing air pollution.

New Laws for Cleaner Air

The Killer Smog of 1952 changed the way people thought about air pollution. For the first time, there could be no doubt that smog was a deadly problem. Over the next three years, the British government passed laws designed to make air cleaner. Polluting factories were moved outside the city. The government helped people pay for cleaner heating systems that didn’t rely on dirty coal.

America followed with clean-air laws of its own. Since 1955, these laws have supported research on air pollution and imposed limits on the toxins that can be released into the air by factories, power plants, cars, and other sources of pollution.

Since then, there have been no killer smogs in England or America. But dirty air continues to be a problem in many parts of both countries, thanks largely to cars and growing populations.

Smog also remains a truly deadly problem around the world. Beijing, China, and New Delhi, India, are just two of dozens of cities frequently shrouded in pea-soup smogs caused by factories, burning coal, and car exhaust.

According to the World Health Organization, air pollution is the world’s most dangerous environmental problem. Millions suffer from pollution-related health problems such as asthma. In 2012, about 7 million people died from exposure to dirty air.

Few understand the dangers of air pollution better than survivors of the Killer Smog of 1952—like Brian Bone.

Happily, Brian recovered from his illness. But throughout his life, he has suffered from lung problems that may have been caused by the smog.

Today, at age 72, Brian understands what a gift it is to take a deep breath of sweet, fresh air.

Copyright ©2016 Lauren Tarshis

Tuesday, December 8, 2015

CHENG XUEHU/IMAGINECHINA/AP IMAGES

Children wear masks to help protect their lungs from smog. Today, Chinese people rank air pollution as one of their country’s most serious problems.

Smog So Thick, Beijing Comes to a Standstill 

Air pollution in Beijing, China, has become a public health crisis

BEIJING, CHINA—Residents across this city awoke to an environmental state of emergency as poisonous air quality prompted the government to close schools, force drivers off the road, and shut down factories.

On Monday, the government declared a “red alert” over air pollution. It also broadcast what sounded like bombing raid alerts in the subways to warn people of the health dangers. Yet even with those extraordinary measures, the toxic air grew worse, shrouding China’s capital city of more than 20 million people in a soupy, metallic haze.

By 4 p.m., walking the dim streets was like strolling through a coal mine. The city’s air quality index read 308, rated “hazardous” by United States standards. At that level, people should not even set foot outdoors.

Paying the Price

Cities in China regularly have poor air quality. In fact, the air in China is among the worst in the world. Rapid industrialization, burning coal for power, and a quick rise in the number of people who own cars have all contributed to the problem. According to some estimates, as many as 1 million people in China die each year from diseases linked to the polluted air.

Officials in Beijing issued the red alert to try to rein in the smog and to show residents that the government was taking action. During the alert, the number of cars allowed on the road was restricted, so many workers couldn’t get to their jobs. Others had to stay home with their children, as Beijing’s 3,200 schools were ordered to close for several days.

The inconvenience caused by the red alert showed residents just how severe China’s environmental crisis has become.

“What bothers me the most is that my child may have a very negative view of nature,” said café manager Kan Tingting, 35. Tingting remained indoors with her 3-year-old daughter—one of some 2 million schoolchildren affected by the school closures. “She loves nature much less than she would in a normal environment. I don’t want her to grow up thinking nature is ugly.”

In another corner of Beijing, university professor Wang Bei was bunkered down at home with her 10-year-old son. “Air pollution is a huge problem that we ignored early on, while we concentrated on economic development,” she said. “Now we are paying the price.”

YU HONGEN/IMAGINECHINA/CORBIS

It looks like night, but this photo was taken during the morning rush hour in Beijing.

Devil’s Handshake

Beijing has had a color-coded emergency response plan to smog since 2013. Until now, however, it had never sounded a red alert. Many residents wondered why.

Did city officials fear the economic losses that might result?

In recent years, China has made a devil’s handshake: the trading of a healthy living environment for extremely fast economic growth. Now, as government leaders try to deal with this dystopian scenario, many are realizing that lasting change could take years, maybe decades.

“Shutting down factories is not ideal for the economy,” said Zhao Ling, a technology salesman. “But health should come first.”

This article was originally published in the April 2016 issue.

videos (1)
Answer Key (1)
videos (1)
Answer Key (1)

1. PREPARING TO READ

2. READING AND DISCUSSING

3. SKILL BUILDING

Differentiated Writing Prompts
For Struggling Readers

In a well-organized paragraph, explain what positive changes came from the killer smog of 1952.

For Advanced Readers

Have students create a pamphlet, poster, or video about the dangers of air pollution. Students should explain what smog is, why it’s dangerous, and how we can help reduce it. (Tip: Consider having students focus their research on the air quality in your area.)

Literature Connection: Connect to other texts that explore human impact on the environment

Out of the Dust 
by Karen Hesse

The Highest Tide 
by Jim Lynch

Rachel Carson: Fighting Pesticides and Other Chemical Pollutants 
by Patricia Lantier

Text-to-Speech